Tags
acceptance, gender fluid, gender identity, gender non-conforming, gender queer, gender variance, self awareness, self expression, transgender
Lately I’ve been talking to myself about labels. Truly, I am in a fuss about it.
It all started when we were in the lengthy final edit process for Be Who You Are, my first children’s book to be published this fall, and I started looking at the word “transgender” under a microscope. Backward. Forward. Sideways. These days I have been referring to my child’s gender identity as gender non-conforming or gender variant more than trans. Why?
It could be the natural result of time. It could be that we have some new friends in our lives who have sprinkled a new, more generous way of thinking across my brain. Less rigid and more accepting of other alternative paths. Paths that might not be mine or my daughter’s, but still worthy of respect and understanding. I credit these new friends with expanding my awareness into areas that I wasn’t ready to venture into before. Like removing blinders, I gained peripheral vision.
Perhaps I’m using the term “gender non-conforming” to free my child from labels that she didn’t choose. She’s so young that she just knows who she is and doesn’t bother herself with defining what she or other people are called. (How refreshing, right?) When people hear the word “transgender” their mind defaults to sexuality, sex reassignment surgery, adult transexuals, cross dressers, etc. In my experience they don’t normally consider a child who identifies and presents as something other than their birth gender.
I wonder… is it my right to label my child as transgender when she may feel gender queer, gender fluid or some new term we don’t know yet as she gets older? Does my use of ”transgender” limit my child’s full potential? Does it impede her self awareness and internal growth?
When Hope first starting presenting as a girl full time I think I needed to wrap my head around what “transgender” meant. Get up close and personal with the reality of the changes that were happening before my eyes. Maybe I needed some constant, some label to rest my head on like a pillow at the end of the long day? If I can be honest with my heart, maybe I needed an answer, a solution. What I realize most as the days turn into months and now years is that there aren’t any answers. Moreover, there isn’t even a need for a solution because we don’t have a problem.
The reality is that my child does not present as a boy at this moment, but as a girl. That is the snapshot of our lives today and I fully embrace it. I won’t ever have answers for what tomorrow brings and as long as we are true to ourselves there isn’t a need to question. My child may feel differently about her gender identity as time passes. She might not. She might feel comfortable with a label. She might not. Only time tells the remainder of the story.
Tonight I rest my head, comforted by the fact that I no longer require a constant. Awareness blankets and warms me like certainty never did.
i look forward to reading your book.
zion is much happier being the girl she has always been.
gender labeling baffles me too.
seems like folk all my life have tried to ‘box’ me up…
tomboy, androgyne, gender-bender…
don’t really have a comfort zone for boxes and labels, outside of the post office or ups.
the one label i do embrace is ‘queer’.
it seems more all inclusive than gay, bi, trans, lesbian or others.
and queer is not a bad thing…to me it only means ‘different’.
we all are different after all. no one is a carbon copy of anyone else. to be queer seems to me not to be weird, but to be contrary to the truly non-existent ‘norms’ proscribed by an unenlightened societal structure.
most every tradition, from native american tribal peoples, to far-flung cultures across the earth, have made a place of reverence to the weh-wah, the heioka, the sacred ‘clown’.
my queer-ness would have been a source of honor in those cultures. as would zion’s.
she refers to herself as a girl/boy…but only identifies as a girl. the genitalia alone are the ‘boy’ of her. and she can’t wait to get rid of those spare parts.
it is the luck of the draw or divine providence that placed her in my care, this i know.
for she felt safe enough to tell me her deep secret…and my life has uniquely qualified me to be compassionate and supportive.
please, blog or email me when your book is out.
am writing one myself, altho perhaps not to publish as much as to sort things out and keep history (or herstory) for my beautiful daughter…
You are so right Moon- we are all so different. Most of the time I feel like we can live label-free and then I come to a screeching halt other days. I guess that is living, right? I will keep everyone posted on the book and thank you for such kind and beautiful words. Best- Jen
purely for the sake of intellectual inquiry I ask why are people like Hope and myself considered “gender non-conforming”? Particularly in Hope’s case is she not absolutely conforming to her own gender as she KNOWS and FEELS is right for her? The problem is that everyone else made an assumption regarding Hope’s gender because of their perception and preconceived ideas based solely on external sex organs. Unfortunately, when Hope or any other child is born they are not able to tell us what their true gender is because they have not yet developed the tools with which to communicate.
The beautiful thing about young children such as Hope is that they speak from their hearts, knowing what their truth is without first learning that being open and honest can cause others to react out of fear and ignorance against them.
Jen, I do not know how you became so wise, mature, understanding, compassionate, and yes VERY brave but it truly warms my heart just knowing that parents like you exist and just simply love their children unconditionally. Thank you for being you and for allowing Hope to be her true self. What gifts you both offer to the world.
Cheryl
Cheryl- Trust me, I ask myself that ALL the time. Why is it that she is considered gender non-conforming when she is loving true to herself. I guess I struggle with words sometimes like a person trying to elegantly scoop a goldfish out of a bowl with their fingers. It gets messy. I love that you brought a great point to the discussion and that is that we do not know a child’s true gender until they tell us their truth. I like that and it makes complete sense to me. I will be thinking of that for a long time I am sure. I am so grateful for your caring support of all of us. If it wasn’t for people like you I would have remained completely afraid to share our story. Fear kills the reality of our lives. Love makes everything possible and real for me. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. My Best- Jen
I’ve never been one to like labels. I treat people as they are as individuals, not some cultural or societal label or box. And I’ve always just thought of myself without any labels to what people see as my life, person, and be it sex or gender.
I describe to folks as labels are boxes we put people into to make it easier to (mis)understand them, often with emtionally disasterous results, but I’m one of those people who isn’t in any box and peering over the sides I look at the best and the worst of what inside and wander away, along my own journey encountering new boxes and repeating the process, going, “Hmmm…, interesting and thanks but I’ll mosey along now.”
Part of this is due to the fact all those labels and descriptions miss the people who live in the space in between. Whatever box or boxes you want, I’m one of those many who simply existis outside them, and often sadly with its own emotional baggage of being an outsider. But I’m always reminded of someting I wrote awhile ago.
“Take for example the beginning of Mark Twain’s book, “Following the Equator” where there is a photo of him on the steamship above the inscription, “Be good and you will be lonesome.” Well, Jimmy Buffett took it farther in a verse in the song “That’s what living is to me”, when he wrote,
Be good and you will be lonesome.
Be lonesome and you will be free.
Live a lie and you will live to regret it.
That’s what living is to me,
That’s what living is to me.”
I think Twain and Buffett had a broader definition of “good” in their words than normally understood, and more so about just being who you are and striving to be your best at that. I have a lifetime of struggling to conform and fit the good of those box(es), and often still do because it’s convenient or expected. I have learned and can assure you the lie isn’t worth the effort. It only drains the spirit and soul, and in the end, the being itself.
All you, Hope and your son, are doing is simply living to be good and free, trying to be who you are following your own way, letting the rest of the world go theirs, but not without helping and showing them you (as a family) and the rest of us are here, and as normal as anyone in any of those boxes people use to define others.
We are grateful in this age it’s possible to do that and grateful you’ve taken up the challenge. The silent don’t always express it, but rest assured, we’re there and grateful.
You’ve made me so happy Scott!! I have never searched for a Buffet song on iTunes, but by golly, I will now. I love those words and the meaning throughout. I agree with what you said about labels and I struggle. I’ve always been mindful of the people who fall between those boxed in labels and my heart is totally there. I love how your words gently remind me that there isn’t one way in life. There are many and they are wonderful. Thank you for being a beacon Scott. I am so grateful. Best- Jen
Why do you think transgender doesn’t include genderqueer, genderfluid, multigender and all those other things?
Hi ChartreuseFlameThrower- I guess I was trying to relate the struggle I feel with any/all labels really. I hope that makes sense. Best- Jen
Ah, I understand that. Transgender is one of the most open labels, though. Some people apply it to crossdressers and all gender variant people. I can understand not liking the implications of transition and all that, but transgender is a very open label- I don’t think it impedes anything if gender variant doesn’t.
I cannot tell you how much joy I feel in reading what you post, especially this one in particular. I devote much energy in creating an environment for myself that you are giving to your child as a matter of course. I wish you and your family the best of luck in all your endeavors.
Thank you AlextheSane- I am touched by your kind words and wish you my best. Jen
Labels are strange things.
They can free us, confuse us, annoy us and infuriate us depending on how we feel. Like Scott, I function mostly as an outsider; I look at the world objectively and try not to box myself into anything. It can be a very lonely and confusing existence to myself and the friends and family around me.
It’s reached the stage now where I’m just me, and I treat others as individuals. I only use labels if someone confides in me that they are comfortable with them when I explain my strange group of friends to people that aren’t familiar with my life.
I think you’re doing the right thing in constantly looking at yourself and others; picking at your brain is the only way to truly evolve as a person and as a parent. Trying to be enlightened in your life situation may turn out to be occasionally lonely for you and you’re children, but just remember that your positive guidance and energy will rub off on others and help the larger world through your deeds and those of your children.
Hi I found your blog unexpectedly while trying to learn more about gender variance in boys. I too have been feeling very anxious about needing to ‘label’ my child, when in reality there is no need for him to be labelled. Sometimes he wants to dress as a girl, sometimes he doesn’t. Sometimes he wants long flowy hair, other times he doesn’t. Sometimes he wants to rough-house with his brother, sometimes he prefers to play with his Barbies. He is not any ONE thing, except himself. Thank you for this post.
Hi, FWIW, my favourite choice for label, when necessary, is “gender diverse.”
I like gender diverse Miqqi Alicia. We all get tripped up on labeling someone else, it always feels better when the person identifies themself and we take the lead. Feels more respectful to me that way. Thanks, Jen
Pingback: To Parents | Binary Subverter