Tags
community, future, gender identity, gender variance, healing, hiding, media, self awareness, self expression, transgender
If you look for trans individuals in the movies, on tv or in books it’s hard to find. I am guessing if you do find them it’s because gender identity is the story line or helps the story line, not just because.
I keep thinking about S. Bear Bergman’s book, The Nearest Exit May Be Behind You, where he talks about how trans individuals are portrayed in the media, particularly as a deceptive group. Think Crying Game and you get the picture. Then I thought about Candis Cayne, the gorgeous actress who portrayed a trans woman in the tv series Dirty Sexy Money. I loved that she was on prime time, but at the same time I wished it wasn’t in a story line about a politician trying to keep his affair with a trans woman out of the media spotlight. Why couldn’t she have been a boring, but very attractive co-worker or neighbor? I guess that isn’t quite saucy enough.
Who represents our children?
I’ve searched high and low for books that represent my daughter, but I haven’t found a single one. Warning! Tangent- Please do not suggest 10,000 Dresses. Most people who recommend this book do so without reading it first. Trust me, big mistake. It’s one of my daughter’s least favorite books. She actually re-wrote the ending to this book because she and her brother found it so offensive. The main character who is painfully shunned by hir whole family sees a friendly stranger on a porch and goes into their house. Does anyone else see the problem with stranger-danger here? Encouraging vulnerable kids to seek emotional and physical shelter in a (possible) predator’s home is grossly irresponsible.
Since the books, movies and tv shows are lagging behind we just have to keep putting our stories and images out there until the world stops slapping a label on what it means to be transgender and starts seeing all people for who they are- unique, beautiful and yes, different in a good way.
As a result of what you shared here, we have decided to remove “10,000 Dresses” from our recommended reading list. While it’s true that, in a vacuum, any oxygen is welcome if you need it to survive, it’s also true that not all air is healthy air.
As a transwoman who founded two national organizations dedicated to exclusively serving the needs of trans children and youth, I completely agree with your observation that positive and diverse role models are needed for not only the children and youth, but perhaps even more importantly, the parents and caregivers whose support is all-important.
Thank you for your ever thoughtful and inspiring blog.
Jenn Burleton
Executive Director
TransActive Education & Advocacy
Thank you so much Jenn!
Have you read Bill’s New Frock by Anne Fine? It deals as much with gender stereotyping as it does with being transgender. One day Bill wakes up and finds out he is a girl (on the outside at least). Throughout the day he is forced behave like a girl and gets into scrapes because of this. He makes friends with a girl in his class and together they challenge stereotypical views of girls. Fortunately, the next day all is back to normal, but Bill has learnt that girls and boys are equally good and not as different as he thought.
It was made into a drama in 1998 and is available to watch on youtube. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cA7_Qap_M9U
I hadn’t heard if it before Claire- Thanks!! I’ll check it out. Best- Jen
Have you seen the Belgian film Ma Vie En Rose (My Life In Pink)? It’s a favourite of mine. French with English subtitles.
As for books, check out Luna by Julie Anne Peters and Parrotfish by Ellen Wittlinger.
Thanks for all the good info Michael. I have actually written about Luna here. I really enjoyed the book and loaned it to a friend through PFLAG. I’ll look for Parrotfish too. Never heard of it. I saw Ma Vie en Rose a long time ago if I recall. I have to go back to Netflix and watch it again. Best- Jen
this post reminded me of a colouring book about gender stereotyping that i’ve been trying to hunt down. haven’t found it yet, but in my search i found these. a lot of focus is on gender stereotyping / ‘same-sex’ attraction rather than genderqueer or transgender but i thought i’d give you the links anyway. reflection press looks (in my very preliminary research) the most promising. i haven’t vetted them, so if it turns out the sites are obnoxious, i do apologise.
http://www.girlsnotchicks.com/
http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?uid=232285365108&topic=10239
http://www.reflectionpress.org/transgender/coloring.html
Thanks Hannah!! It’s always good to have more options to review than less so I appreciate you passing along some links. I’ll check them out. Best- Jen